Sunday, June 15, 2014

WHEN THINGS FALL APART

When things fall apart, there is a frenzy to fix the blame on this or that individual in a position of political power. And there are plenty of candidates for “who” is to blame for particular aspects of recent fiascos highlighted by the tragedy engulfing Iraq and Syria.

William Kristof, in yesterday’s NY Times, blames Maliki mainly, but assigns a share to Obama (for failing to intervene militarily in Syria) and parenthetically to Bush (although he treats that as a matter of history, no longer particularly relevant to dealing with the current crisis). David Brooks, along with John McCain and hawks in both parties, has it in for Obama for “under reach” in the exercise of US military power. In the blame contest, the easiest bipartisan consensus is that the main fault is with Maliki, as with Karsai in Afghanistan, whose corrupt and autocratic regimes of our own creation failed to bow totally to demands for long term US intervention as military overseer.

It’s time to focus on “what”, more than “who”, is to blame. One trouble with putting all the onus on one individual culprit versus another is the implication that a different tactical decision here or there about how to deploy US armed forces could have made our military intervention a success and stabilized (pacified?) the Middle East. Yet the last half of the 20th century and the first part of the 21st show beyond doubt that war and military power, however superior in favor of the United States, don’t produce “victory”, don’t bring peace and compliance, and almost always make matters more dangerous. No matter how often and how hard we bring down the hammer, solutions to problems within and among nations fail to take shape.

Beyond debates over whom to blame when violence and chaos create an acute crisis, the question becomes what do we do now, right now? Of course there never is a magic short term answer when deep antagonisms — especially nationalist, ethnic, and religious — erupt into warfare that victimizes millions, engulfs nations and regions, and endangers the world community. The first essential is not to do more harm through another futile resort to US military intervention. The only helpful response is to participate urgently in building a coalition of all nations and groups who have a common interest in stemming the tide of war in Iraq and Syria and organizing massive humanitarian relief. Whether our hawks like it or not, that collective effort has to include assumed US adversaries Iran and Russia, as well as the United Nations. The Bush Administration courted the UN notoriously in the run-up to its invasion of Iraq. Maybe US support for a coalition of all who want to end war in the Middle East could yield greater success and breath life into lingering hopes for an effective UN.

There is no escaping the need for a longer view, not just an “emergency response”. We are in a time when “things fall apart”. (Those three words are the title of a novel by Nigerian author Chinua Achebe, who describes the collapse of African communal society as colonial intervention took root.) The violent ethnic and religious conflicts of today have deep roots, and have been exploited and nurtured in a long history of Western colonialism and post-colonial imperialism. Now the economic and political system that fashioned and dominates the present world order cannot keep it under control. More than anything, its increasingly dysfunctional state and decline are the product of widening chasms of extreme inequality that fuel antagonisms within and among nations.

At some stage, a process of fundamental change has to take hold in a more equalitarian and humane direction. That has been what socialists of different stripes have understood. The notion that far flung US military power can sustain a failing economic order, that it can by force keep things from falling apart, is as irrational as other messianic currents plaguing our world.

I’m not happy to wind up this longer than usual blog on a note of “I don’t know”. Who knows how, when or even if the ways to serious social change can come together before everything falls apart?  Past 90, one may feel that life is very long. Each generation, though, only has a very short time in human history, not long enough to foresee or guarantee the future. Yet, over many generations, humanity is resilient and the struggle for liberty, equality and, ultimately, for survival is refreshed. That’s what makes for hope, and may also make the impossible possible:  “we shall overcome some day.”

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

NEWS OF THE DAY

The news that grabs me today:  Of course, there is the demolition of Eric Cantor; also, the California judge’s ruling against teacher tenure.

It’s sad that many parents who are outraged by the disastrously low quality of education think that the answer is a war to get rid of bad teachers and to weaken teacher’s unions. Not surprisingly, inadequate teachers and bad schools plague poor and minority communities especially. But things have taken a bizarre turn in the name of “education reform”. Instead of an emphasis on preparing and recruiting many more good teachers, of making teaching attractive and highly valued by society, of investing in better schools and educational support, the thrust is to make it easier to fire teachers, to demonize unions, to devalue and shrink public schools.

Sad, too, that many liberals who are solidly against the wars on women, on the unemployed and the homeless, on voting rights, and so on, nevertheless, buy into the anti-union thrust of purported “education reform”. Whatever improvements need to be made in teacher evaluation and performance through strong interaction between parents, educators, and unions, there is little question as to what outlawing tenure would mean. Further weakening unions would do nothing to make teaching more attractive. Rather it would give unlimited power over hiring, firing, conditions of work and educational process to those in authority. That would open the way to arbitrariness, acts of personal and political prejudice, such as sullied the practices of many education administrators when conformity was demanded at the expense of civil liberties.

No wonder that war against teacher and public employee unions is top priority for Scott Walker, the Koch brothers and ALEC: just leave everything up to the boss.

* * *

How can one not get a charge out of what happened to Eric Cantor? Just desserts! Still, there is a queasy feeling. One can hope that this stunning turn of events will weaken the GOP’s electoral prospects, but there’s more reason for alarm than for celebration in the Tea Party’s promotion of anti-immigrant and racist poison.

I wonder who is most pained by Cantor’s debacle. There is AIPAC and Netanyahu, for whom Cantor was foremost champion in Congress of total support for Israel’s occupation regime; he also tried his darndest to undermine any negotiations with Iran. Then there is David Brooks and others trying to save the GOP through a “new” conservative agenda, one with a more human face, one that acknowledges the concerns of ordinary folk.

The last time this “new” Republican thinking tried to makeover a harsh public image, we got “compassionate conservatism” with George W. Bush. ‘Not this time’, according to Cantor’s nemesis, David Brat, and the Tea Party cohort. The prevailing GOP winds are not going the way of the “new” (once again?) reformers.

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

DIMINUENDO



Every so often my “blog” lapses into silence. It’s not because of health problems (I’m still lucky to be in good condition despite ripe old age). I haven’t stopped paying attention to the news and it’s certainly not that I’ve stopped caring.

It is, though, a matter of mood. I begin to look at my blogging with a “so what?” feeling. I’ve said my say for so long that the urge wanes. Do I want to throw more words at problems that never seem to go away? I know that hope and struggle are eternal, but there are always new and younger voices that suit the times.

Life still affords me pleasures that I appreciate: family and friends (those gone far outnumber those around me), more reading than ever (even with old eyes that need a Kindle instead of a book), music still, although most plays now lull me to sleep. I blog now and then, often walk around Lake Merritt with Gail and our friends, and co-lead a weekly Current Events session at the main Oakland Senior Center.

I know I will have the urge to write something from time to time. And I still feel “responsible” to my Friday friends in Current Events. But I think I’d like to give myself permission to stay quiet more often than not, and to miss a Friday session every few weeks.

I’m aware that there aren’t many out there who eagerly await an explanation when my blogs become infrequent. But I feel better explaining it to myself and passing it along.

Friday, May 2, 2014

AFTER KERRY'S MISSION

Is there anything new to be taken from Kerry’s frenzied and failed effort to broker a deal between Netanyahu and Abbas? Maybe not really “new”, but definitive, clear as clear can be.

Israel’s ruling circles are dead set against a Palestinian state. They don’t want it because they are bent on continued colonial expansion in the occupied territories. The strategic goal of the ultra Right, which exerts powerful pressure on Israeli government policy, is to take over all of so-called “biblical Israel”, to drive Palestinians out, to create a permanent Jewish majority by any means necessary.

The government of the United States, even when its interests come into collision with Israeli policy, is fully committed to preserving its huge military and economic investment in Israel as its strongest ally in the Middle East. Moreover, persistent lobbying, political funding and media bias have sustained a narrative in which criticism of Israel is treated as unpatriotic or anti-Semitic. That has begun to change, notably within the Jewish community, but it remains a major obstacle to a substantive shift in US policy.

Once and for all, the Kerry mission proved that the United States can’t and won’t “solve” the Israeli/Palestine conflict.

So what now?  Is there a different way to go toward ending the occupation?

To begin with, the Palestinians are fully justified in disregarding the Israeli ultimatum “forbidding” reconciliation and elections to establish unified leadership and representation for Palestine. They have every right and reason to advance their cause within the UN and to muster support internationally for an end to the occupation. In fact, the status quo can’t be changed without unremitting worldwide condemnation of the occupation.

Netanyahu’s cohorts try in vain to censor the word that keeps cropping up: “apartheid”. It was spoken years ago by Jimmy Carter when he warned that the settlers were creating “facts on the ground” that would block any future agreement. It was spoken by Bishop Tutu and now, despite a forced and half-hearted apology, by John Kerry. Tom Friedman and other longtime partisans of Israel have warned that the movement for “Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions” is amassing support as a growing challenge to the occupation.

The picture can change when a majority of Israelis reject colonial rule over Palestine as shameful and unsustainable, incompatible with a democratic Israel. The days when colonialism was accepted, even advertised as benevolent, are over. 

New avenues to reconciliation, justice and peace may be found once a broader base in international support replaces the exclusive, unbalanced and futile US brokered “peace process”. In any case, experience old and new proves that ultra nationalism and religious fundamentalism – whether Jewish, Muslim, or Christian — yields only isolation, tragedy and ultimate despair.

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

COURTS CHANGE LIVES

By its latest shameful edict supporting bans against affirmative action, the Roberts Court proved again the truth of what Justice Sotomayor declared in powerful dissent: race matters! The decision also showed that courts matter: they change lives.

A graphic in the New York Times (4/22/2014) shows that in states that have banned affirmative action, the gap between the percentage of black and Hispanic residents of college age and the those admitted to the main state universities has swelled. The gap is most dramatic in California for Hispanic youth. Worse still, the percentage of black freshmen at UC Berkeley is 2%, and at UCLA it’s 3%.

Read that not as “statistics”, but as dreams deferred, young lives discounted. Anyone who has ever been involved in college admissions knows outstanding doctors and others in worthwhile careers who would never have had a chance without affirmative action: conscious efforts to counter the crushing inequality of opportunity imposed by racism. Nor would we have Supreme Court Justice Sotomayer. (That goes for Justice Thomas as well, although he needed a full court press by a GOP establishment that exploits racism as a cornerstone of its political strategy.)

The Roberts Court has set me to imagining what might have been if its present majority had been around to decide cases from 1954 to 1969. I can’t help thinking how my life, among countless others, might have turned out very differently. These were years in which major decisions advanced civil rights in education and voting, and in striking down Jim Crow laws. These were years in which many outrages rampant under “McCarthyism” were declared unconstitutional or checked by the Supreme Court. Of course the vital force that propelled positive actions by the federal courts (and the Executive branch) was grass roots struggle, with much courage and sacrifice.

In the rebound from McCarthyism starting in 1954, the federal courts gutted the Smith Act, two McCarran Acts, and the “loyalty oaths” that were imposed on academia and the teaching profession. Overruled were government demands for membership lists of organizations deemed “subversive” as well as the denial of passports to critics of US policies.  By the time the unconstitutional witch hunts were overturned, step by step over more than a decade, dozens had served long prison terms, some were crippled and even killed in prison, thousands were barred or forced out of jobs, and inquisitions run by racist dominated “Un-American” committees had invaded every corner of American life.

To make it personal, I was cited under the McCarran Internal Security Act in 1954 and denied an academic position at the State University of New York in 1964 because of the terms of the Feinberg “loyalty” law. If the McCarran Act had been upheld, I would have been ordered to turn over the membership lists of the Labor Youth League. When (not if) I refused, the penalty by law was 5 years in jail and $5,000 fine for each day of refusal to comply! Justice Scalia, who enjoys a joke, would have found that hilarious.

Courts change lives. The Roberts Court has slammed its door on on the aspirations of America’s young people of color for equality of opportunity.

Sadly, the Supreme Court is currently the most functional branch of the federal government.  This is not the first time in our history that it has endorsed racial oppression. But the Roberts Court can be reigned in if the forces of political climate change are progressive and determined — that may be suggested by the inability of the Roberts majority to stem the tide of Gay Rights. Sooner rather than later, a prime democratic objective has to be to override the Roberts majority’s contempt for democracy and the people who constitute Romney’s 47% (or should that be 99%?).

It’s far from easy, but the Court has to be changed for the better in the next several years, or it will continue changing lives for the worse.

Friday, April 11, 2014

MUSICIANS AS POLITICAL TARGETS

Anthony Tommasini, music critic of The New York Times, recently wrote a long article about political pressure on some leading musicians to protest policies of their respective governments. The focus was on two brilliant conductors, Gustavo Dudamel of Venezuela and Valery Gergiev of Russia.

How artists interact with society is a venerable and complicated question, and Tommasini’s article is certainly timely. I am fond of Tommasini as a music critic, whose judgments are insightful and never insensitive. But in this article, I think conventional (conformist) political narratives limit his objectivity.

Tommasini appreciates Dudamel’s concern and devotion to the young musicians drawn from poverty-stricken areas into the remarkably successful El Sistema, nurtured under successive Venezuelan governments. But he takes for granted the narrative of those pressuring Dudamel to condemn his government. Dudamel has spoken against violence and for the right of protest. I don’t know his views on the huge divide between rich and poor in Venezuela, or on the US State Department’s history of intervention and support for coups against democratically elected governments in Latin America, including in Venezuela. But it’s a disgrace to gang up on him for not going along with “our” side as defined by “our” media. And if his main concern is protecting El Sistema and its thousands of young artists, that establishes him as a real hero to go along with his place among the world’s foremost musicians.

The Gergiev story is not straightforward, but some similarities appear. Human rights issues are necessarily of international concern, whether involving suppression of social protest or repression based on race, ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation. The Russian government is among those with intolerable restrictions denying Gay rights, and those policies should be protested everywhere. Gergiev’s position on the issue is limited to the assertion that his orchestras don’t discriminate, far from a convincing declaration of conscience and social responsibility. But it’s quite another matter to demand that Gergiev and Anna Netrebko, the celebrated opera singer, denounce their government and take “our” side in the renewed antagonism between the “West” and Russia.

The problem with Tommasini’s version is its conformity to “official” legend. Apparently it's not bothersome to pressure artists from Venezuala and Russia, while ignoring the outcry against repression by regimes considered our "allies". Tommasini does give a passing salute to Zubin Meta, the conductor of the Israeli Philharmonic, for publicly opposing the settlements and occupation policies of the Israeli government. But few of Israel’s outstanding musicians have spoken up against the colonial occupation and suppression of the Palestinians.

Nor in Tommasini’s essay is there a glance in the mirror, no hint that musicians in the United States may have an obligation to speak out on a host of oppressive foreign and domestic policies. Some of our artists have taken stands of dissent, including in periods of repression when it wasn’t easy. That arises from conscience, persuasion and courage when necessary, not from political targeting.

There is something wrong about what Tommasini calls the “Political Cacophony” challenging musicians. Making Dudamel and Gergiev convenient foreign targets is more a matter of political manipulation than of social responsibility. It’s hard to be taken seriously about human rights when selective focus conforms to prevailing political bias.


Friday, April 4, 2014

THEN AND NOW...

After too many years to count, I found myself back in a high school classroom yesterday and again today. Kevin, my grandson, is teaching English literature and two of his classes have read Arthur Miller’s “The Crucible” and seen a movie about McCarthyism. I was invited to be interviewed about the McCarthy years as I experienced them.

For an hour in each class we talked about “witch hunts” and related issues going back to my parents’ time, starting during World War I, and my own memories from childhood up to the present. As you may imagine, everything was on the table: the struggles and contributions of “reds” to social progress; communism and “red scares”; the FBI’s hounding of civil rights and anti-war activists; present day “surveillance”, deportations and racial profiling — too long a list to fill out here.


There was a warm feeling of connection despite more than seven decades of separation by age. We enjoyed and respected each other. For me, it was a wonderful time. It brightened my day even after the latest 5-4 abomination by the Roberts Court.